Do Dog Electric Fences Really Work
Edward R. Forte
October 25, 2021
Gates, Doors, And Pens
For people who are afraid of dogs, don't like their lawns dotted with feces, and dislike muddy paw prints on the patio, the relationship is clear - if a dog owner keeps his dog in his own yard, he's a good neighbor.But being neighborly isn't the only reason for fencing in dogs.Fenced-in dogs are less likely to be hit by vehicles, have fewer aggressive interactions with other dogs, have decreased exposure to contagious diseases, and are less available to pet thieves.Invisible electric fences are often less costly even when professionally installed.Invisible fences are, well, invisible.Once the dog learns the boundaries of the electric fence, the flags can be removed.Intruders may be deterred by the presence of a dog in the yard since they aren’t likely to realize that the dog may not actually be able to reach them.This requires a training period where the owner and dog walk the perimeter of the fence noting the flags.Although invisible fences protect dogs by preventing them from leaving the yard, they do not prevent hazards from entering the yard.Most electric fences include an audible warning prior to the electric impulse and dogs learn quickly to respect the “beep” to avoid the shock.When a dog ignores the audible signal, an electric stimulus is discharged which startles the dog but is not painful if the apparatus is set appropriately.If the dog sees something he really wants to chase or is frightened by thunder or something inside the yard, he may breach the electric fence ignoring the electric stimulus. .
Do Underground Fences Work?
Or what if you have too much property to make a fence practical?For some dog owners, this sounds too good to be true.Collars that work with underground fences can be set at different levels, depending on your dog's sensitivity.Underground fencing systems can only be used with dogs who weigh at least 8 pounds.Underground fences are perfect for keeping pets contained with a little DIY installation and training.You can enjoy the yard together without worrying about your pet wandering off. .
Invisible Fences: Do or Don't?
I want to acknowledge at the outset that this this can be a hot-button issue for many dog owners and trainers, with strong feelings on all sides – and that’s perfectly okay.And truthfully, for some of my clients, I have seen them work quite well without any apparent problems.“Invisible Fence“ is actually a specific brand of something called an underground containment system for dogs.As technology has advanced, there are now some variations available on this same basic idea – wireless systems that cover a circular area up to a certain distance from the transmitter, and even GPS-based models that allow you to “enclose” very large or irregularly-shaped swaths of land.By and large, most dog owners who use an Invisible Fence do so with the best of intentions.These are valid goals, meant to make the dog’s life better.Some subdivisions have strict rules against any type of fencing – homeowners may not realize this until after they’ve moved in and added a dog to the family.Physical fencing is also quite expensive, as anyone who has priced it knows!Sometimes, there are no perfect solutions – all we can do is our best.Although it all sounds great on paper, using shock-based corrections in this way is a delicate balancing act.Unfortunately, the “correct” level of shock for any given dog is extremely hard to predict.But we’re forgetting something very important – he may also associate the shock with anything else that happens to be nearby at the time, which can result in some unexpected problems.See my previous post about Heidi the German Shepherd for a particularly striking example of this phenomenon.But there’s no surefire way to predict which dogs will develop a problem, and which ones won’t – so you should be aware that it’s a risk.As anyone who has worked in an animal shelter can tell you, it’s distressingly common to see lost dogs wearing electronic fence collars.Dogs can also be harassed or stolen by unscrupulous people if there is no physical fence to protect them.If you do choose to use an underground fence system for your dog, I would recommend the following:.Be aware of what the risks are, and watch for any problems. .
Top 6 Hidden Fence Myths Addressed
Many people feel that “shocking” a dog is harmful and an inhumane method of training.With the proper training ALL breeds of dogs can be trained to a hidden fence.This type of fencing does work – which is why any reputable company will offer you a money-back guarantee if they cannot contain your dog.They should also offer training assistance if you experience any sort of problems – it only makes sense to stand behind your product.Some people believe that dogs will become aggressive if they are contained with a hidden fence.Our customers, however, overwhelmingly report that their dogs are much happier when they have the freedom to play outside without a leash or chain.For example, a dog who has never been properly socialized may not be comfortable around strangers.Many people mistakenly believe that hidden fencing is very expensive so they never even explore the possibility of using it for their pets.In addition, a system purchased from an Authorized Hidden Fence Dealer will be properly installed by an experienced professional who will also ensure that your pet is trained to understand the fence, thereby increasing the likelihood of successful containment.Although hidden fencing isn’t for everyone, we hope that addressing some of these more popular myths associated with it will help open your mind to the possibilities. .
Wireless dog fence
When considering installing an electronic dog fence one of the factors will be “do I need to install a boundary wire?Traditionally this involved digging or installing a circuit of boundary wire to keep the cat or dog contained.A wireless fence cannot be used with houses that have a mobile phone signal booster or smart meter.If the zone does not cover every inch of the property it is not quite so crucial.With a UK garden if the owner has a fence running around the boundary and the installs an interior circular zone this is confusing for the dog.Most owners will agree that boundary wobble is unfair for the pet the if the wireless dog fence is being added as a secondary fence it may not be quite such an important issue.No boundary wire to lay – so cable cannot be damaged.The advantage that a wired dog fence has over the wireless fence is that it can be used for any shape of property, on any terrain.Also the FM systems* guarantee no false activation on the pets collar both internally and externally so the collar can be worn both inside and outside.*Dog Fence UK are the only electronic dog fences worldwide to us an FM signal.If an FM system is used there is guaranteed no false activation on the collar.The training time for both wired and wireless dog fences should be the same and this will be dependent on the size of the area, age and breed of dog. .
The Debate On Electronic Dog Fences Continues
“They just make it very difficult if you do something they don’t like,” she says.Instead, the dog hears a warning beep from the collar and then the owner shouts, dances, sings—whatever it takes to get the dog to retreat from the line and go to his person for some tasty treats and praise.But, no matter how well the dog learns to stop when he hears the warning beep, for the system to be effective, the collar must be worn at all times when the dog is in the yard.Shock collars are an aversive tool, which means they use pain and/or fear to motivate the dog to stay in the yard.“Sighthounds will chase anything they see,” he says, “plastic bags, leaves, rabbits, pretty much anything.” And because Greyhounds are fast—40- miles-per-hour fast—by the time they hear the shock collar’s warning beep, they are likely to be on the other side of the boundary before they come to a stop, if they do at all.“I didn’t train them,” she says.Beyond the system not working out, any time a dog feels pain or is hurt, there’s a risk of fallout behaviors developing, says Niki Tudge, certified dog trainer and behavior consultant and president of the Pet Professional Guild.Not only can the system not be used in the front yard, but the owner must be with the dog when the dog is outside.Municipalities that do include information on electronic fences generally state that they cannot be used for any dog with a history of aggression.“The dog does not come out of the yard.If she comes out of the yard, she gets shocked.Given accounts such as these, as well as the basic question of whether it is ever okay to use pain or fear to train a dog, it’s unsurprising that the collars are banned in other countries.While groups, including the Pet Professional Guild, lobby to ban shock collars in the United States, some rescue organizations— Sighthound groups among them—will not adopt any dog to a home that uses an electronic fence.One client who was scheduled for an installation had to cancel because his dog was on a tie-out and ran in pursuit of an animal.“I would rather see a dog on Invisible Fence than a tie-out any day,” says Karow.“We certainly want people to be cognizant of the pros and cons and safety concerns of electronic fencing,” says Cory Smith, director of pet protection and policy, “but at the end of the day, if an electronic fence is what is going to allow somebody to keep their pet by eliminating some kind of problem, then we want them to do it.”.“We love it,” she says. .
Invisible fence for cows
It works a little like the invisible yard fencing for dogs.The broadcast system can work in a radius of 5 to 6 miles of the controller.“A year from now, I’ll be able to tell you a lot more,” he says about commercial availability.“What I do know is that it can cost $15,000 to $20,000 per mile to build a permanent fence, and this could eliminate that.”.He says that just like cattle get used to electric fences, they get used to the invisible system, knowing when to move and quickly finding their new boundaries. .