Are Dog Crates Good Or Bad
Edward R. Forte
November 25, 2021
Crates & Kennels
It is my humble opinion that the dog crate is one of the most awesome inventions to hit the world of Dog Stuff since the tennis ball.If properly introduced to his crate, a dog will come to treat it as his bedroom, a safe retreat from the stress of life with those crazy two-legged members of his family.It is not uncommon for dogs to seek out their crate when they need a nap.Puppies under four months of age can hold it in their crate for a maximum of three hours.No dog should be ever be crated more than five or six hours per day.-Pick a room of your house, like the kitchen, and “dog-proof” it so that you can confine your dog here.An occasional time-out when your dog is playing too rough is OK, but your dog is supposed to associate the crate with good things, not bad things.Bottom line, your dog’s crate can be a great tool, as long as you don’t overuse it and don’t use it as punishment. .
A Trainer's Truth About Crates
Dogs have a natural denning instinct, normally preferring safe, enclosed quarters for their naps.Rest periods in snug quarters are a natural part of caring for our dogs’ needs.The two most common models are plastic, such as those required for airplane transport, and collapsible metal wire crates.Provided they are of adequate size (see below), either model will serve equally well as dual-purpose den and training tool.The bottom can be covered with a blanket or thick towel for warmth and comfort.Crates are virtually essential for any dog that isn’t yet housetrained.In turn, this gives you the opportunity to congratulate him with a walk, game or treat—the perfect housetraining scenario.For older dogs who may have poor bladder control, make sure you cover your crate mat or bed with an easy-to-clean cover (try 4Knines Waterproof dog bed liner) to protect against mold and ensure the crate is always a clean and comfortable space for your dog to be in.Or if you want to tire out your puppy more before the crate nap, try running through some quick training exercises and using a more vigorous playtime as a training reward.Trainers will often divide the plan for fixing a behaviour problem into two components, training and management.With young puppies we use the crate to manage a whole raft of anticipated problems, such as destructive chewing, nipping at young children, and housesoiling, when unable to supervise them properly.A good rule of thumb is that a dog can be crated overnight and for up to half the day, provided his social and physical needs are being met while not in the crate.Gradually they can be left on their own with the door closed, and many will readily go to their crate voluntarily for naps or in the hopes that a stuffed chewtoy will miraculously appear.If you aren't sure, take puppy out of the crate very matter-of-factly and place him outside.(Carry the puppy instead of allowing him to meander at his own speed.).Otherwise, the rule of thumb for crate whiners or barkers is that they need to be quiet for at least three minutes straight before they get let out.Otherwise, they are learning that whining and barking works—and then who is training whom? .
Animal Rights Uncompromised: Crating Dogs and Puppies
Crate training does not speed up the housetraining process.It is counterproductive to crate young puppies in the hope that they will “hold it.” They are physically incapable of doing so and are eventually forced to urinate in their crates after experiencing great discomfort while trying not to soil their beds.Pet store and puppy mill puppies, who are born and raised in crate-like structures, tend to be difficult to housetrain, and they may experience severe anxiety and develop fearful and/or destructive behavior if they are confined to crates.When there is a better, more humane way to train dogs, why would we subject our canine companions to a training method that is obviously not in their best interests?PETA does not oppose keeping a dog confined to a small area as necessary if it is in the dog’s best interests (e.g., when complete rest is ordered by a veterinarian or when confinement will keep the dog safe during travel).Committed caretakers who successfully complete training and continue to provide their dogs with rewards for good behavior can be confident that their dogs will not engage in destructive behavior while they are away.For those who cannot make it home during the day to provide their dogs with a potty break and some attention, PETA recommends hiring a reputable pet service or soliciting a reliable person, perhaps a neighbor or relative, to take one’s dog out for a midday walk.A “doggie door” that provides access to a secure yard with a privacy fence is another option for giving dogs the opportunity to relieve themselves as well as for alleviating boredom and preventing neurotic behavior. .
Is a dog crate really a den? How this very American practice took off
They put out this pamphlet called “A Pet Owners Guide To The Dog Crate.”.As The Pet Owner Sees It: “It’s like a jail – it’s cruel – I’d never put MY dog in a cage like that!” If this is your first reaction to using a crate, you are a very typical pet owner.”.“I don’t know if he was you know, a breeder, or rescue, or just a guy that had a lot of dogs.”.“It says that the space that an animal must have, it’s a minimum of 20 square meters,” he said.A dog crate just has to be big enough for the animal to stand, and turn around.And it’s not just Italians.“I read in those books that you could teach your dog to go in a crate and, feel happy in the crate and sleep in the crate.Siracusa says he thinks part of it is convenience, and this American idea that if you want a dog, it’s your right to have one.“But it’s very common in Europe that people will say ‘I don’t think you can get a dog.And there is a sudden noise and they get scared, then they cannot run away,” he said.Or even never leave a dog in a crate when you go to work.Instead, he says you have to always interrogate, ‘are you doing this for your dog or for you?“Our love to animals is not enough,” he said.He says the crate, shouldn’t be the rule, the norm, and that’s not just because it’s small.They need us.“We have created an animal that is very dependent on us, [depends on us] to pee, to poop, to eat, to do anything,” he said.Siracusa says with this in mind there’s a danger the crate can become an excuse: To stay out later, to take your time getting home from this errand or that.I can end up tricking myself into thinking ‘my dog’s in a crate, it’s his den, he likes it, and, well, it’s locked.“And they’re like, ‘oh, there’s nothing else you can do.You have to put this dog down.’ So I was working with dogs who, literally, I was their last resort,” she said.In these cases the crate was the only thing that kept them from destroying the house — the only thing that worked.“My main thing is just don’t put the dog down if it doesn’t want the treat,” she said.So maybe the crate can do some good, make dogs easier for us, and maybe that keeps some from getting returned to Rogers at the Morris Animal Refuge, or worse, to an overflowing kill shelter. .
Crating Dogs, Good or Bad?
Dogs like den-like crates so select an enclosed crate like the one pictured in this article.The rule of thumb is to put the crate in an area that is not highly trafficked such as a bedroom, laundry room or any room that is off the main drag and doesn’t have a line-of-sight to all the activity going on in the main part of the house.Your goal is to slowly get your dog comfortable with the crate by throwing treats inside, initially feeding your dog in the crate and very slowly increasing the amount of time he or she is in the crate with the door closed.In homes with multiple dogs, it is always advisable to have one crate for each of your dogs.Finally, when your dog is not in his or her crate, leave the door open so he or she can freely go in and out of the crate.When a crate is properly set up per the guidelines above, most dog owners are quite surprised how often their dogs will voluntarily spend time in their crate.This is a reliable indicator that you have done a good job of setting up and acclimating your dog to his or her crate. .
Dog Crates/Kennels: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Just recently, Glen Allen Professional Dog Trainer, Melaina, returned home to a nightmare.Her precious border collie, Posey, whom she had left in an airline crate for only a couple of hours, had lodged her jaw into the crate’s door and was unable to get loose.Fortunately, Melaina had some wire cutters nearby and was able to cut Posey loose.tends to categorize safe from unsafe only in terms of car crash safety.Even with a high safety rating, every dog crate has components that can be dangerous given the right (or should I say “wrong”) circumstances.At this point, you can’t help but wonder if crating is too dangerous for a pet, right?Maybe we should reword that sentence by saying, providing a safe crate is one of the most loving things you can do for your pet.After Melaina’s incident with Posey, she is adamant about dog crate safety.Never leave your dog’s collar on while they are in their crate.Collars can get caught on openings and wires, leading to injury or strangulation.If your dog suffers from separation anxiety, approach crate training with caution.We recommend you talk with Holiday Barn Pet Resort’s Professional Dog Trainers prior to leaving an anxious pup in a crate.Regardless of your dog’s age, try not to crate them for more than 5 hours, with the exception being overnight while everyone is sleeping.We recommend a good exercise session prior to crating, especially when they will be crated for an extended time.Cover any grid flooring as it can be very uncomfortable on their precious paws.You can learn your dog’s preferences by staying close and observing their first several crating sessions.You can learn your dog’s preferences by staying close and observing their first several crating sessions Lastly, consider purchasing two crates: One for your dog at home and one for the car.For the safety of your dog and all other passengers, the car kennel must have a means of anchoring it to your vehicle to keep it from coming loose in an accident.Melaina had no reason to believe that anything like this would ever happen with Posey.Posey is very well trained and had shown absolutely no kennel anxiety in the past. .
Dog Crate Training: Pros, Cons, Tips, and Alternatives
You can keep your pooch safe and comfortable while you’re at work by crate training a dog or a puppy.Yet, when done right, puppy crate training can be a solution for leaving a dog home alone.Leaving a Puppy Home Alone in a Crate.Leaving your fur-friend in a crate can prevent these destructive behaviors while you are not home.Another reason you should leave a puppy home alone in a crate is safety.The biggest concern with puppy crate training is the time they spend in the crate.How Long Should a Dog/Puppy Be in a Crate?If you have to work an 8-hour shift, your puppy can’t stay in the crate that long.If you can’t do this yourself, see if someone else can do it for you or consider hiring a dog walker.If your furry friend is sick and can’t hold it in, crate time should go down.If your dog starts to panic around and inside of their crate or has separation anxiety, you should avoid using a crate.You could keep your pup in a puppy-proofed area in your home and monitor them with Petcube Bites, a pet camera that will dispense treats and allow you to check in vocally with a word of praise now and then.Puppy Crate Training While at Work.Puppy crate training is a good option for leaving a dog home alone.While some dogs appreciate their privacy and do well in plastic crates with a grate in the front, breeds such as bulldogs or pugs will do better with more ventilation in a metal crate.Take the dog for a walk before and after leaving them in a crate so they don’t have accidents in the crate.Once your dog learns that the crate is a safe, happy place, they will like spending time there, and you won’t have problems.Alternatives To Puppy Crate Training While At Work.If you’re still not a big fan of crates, there are plenty of alternatives for leaving your dog home alone while at work.The first alternative is, take your dog to work with you!If your workplace is pet-friendly and your pooch is well-behaved, there is no reason not to bring them with you when you are working long shifts.If you can’t take your dog to work, always keep in mind that your dog needs proper daily exercise, access to water (and some treats), and needs to stay safe while you are away.Whether you’re leaving a dog in a crate or letting them roam the premises, make sure you walk them before you go and as soon as you get back.If you have a happy, healthy, well-adjusted dog, there’s no reason not to consider crating them during the day.You Should Not Crate Your Dog When...You will be away for more than 4-5 hours if you have a puppy or more than 8 hours if you have an adult dog.Yet, if you have to leave a dog home alone for long periods of time every day, you might want to consider taking your dog to work, hiring a dog walker, or taking your pooch to a doggie daycare.When done right, puppy crate training is a safer alternative, and your dog might even love their crate.How long is too long to leave a dog in a crate?Adult dogs shouldn’t be left in crates for more than 6-8 hours.Puppies of 17 weeks and older can handle up to 4 or 5 hours in a crate at a time.Some dogs can be left alone for up to 10 hours during the day and not make a scene.It’s best not to leave puppies alone for more than two hours during the day.If you have a puppy, you shouldn’t leave them alone overnight. .
The Benefits of Crate Training
What is a dog crate?Can house train your dog quickly by using the confinement to encourage control, establish a regular routine for outdoor elimination, and prevent accidents at night or when your dog is left alone.Can travel with your dog safely and be assured that she will more easily adapt to strange surroundings as long as she has her familiar “security blanket,” her crate.Your dog needs to feel that he is a part of the family, and that feeling of belonging comes from being included in family activities and living in the house even when her family may not be there.A crate allows you to leave her in the house when you are away, or unable to supervise her. .